There’s just something about a steaming bowl of potato soup that hits the spot, right? But to make it even better, the best sandwich for potato soup is the key. A well-paired sandwich isn’t just a sidekick—it’s the perfect complement that takes your meal to the next level. Whether you’re craving a classic grilled cheese or a hearty turkey and Swiss, the right sandwich can elevate the flavors of your creamy potato soup and make every bite even more satisfying.
Let’s dive in (well, not literally dive into the soup, haha, but you get what I mean)!
Why Does Potato Soup Need a Sandwich?
Okay, okay, I hear you—potato soup is pretty darn good on its own. It’s rich, creamy, and full of flavor. But when you add a sandwich into the mix, it takes the whole experience up a notch. The crunchy, savory elements of a well-made sandwich balance out the creamy texture of the soup, and if you’re smart about it, you can complement the flavors perfectly.
Think of it like this: your soup is the warm, comforting hug, and the sandwich? Well, it’s like the cool, crispy high-five. Together, they make for an unbeatable duo.
So, without further ado, let’s talk about the best sandwiches to pair with that creamy, dreamy bowl of potato soup!
1. Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Ah, the grilled cheese. Is there any sandwich more iconic when it comes to pairing with soup? I mean, c’mon, it’s like the classic combo that everyone knows and loves. The crispy, buttery exterior gives way to gooey melted cheese, and when dipped into that rich potato soup? Pure heaven.
If you want to take it up a notch (because let’s face it, a basic grilled cheese is pretty awesome but sometimes we want a little flair), try adding in extras like crispy bacon, tomatoes, or even a bit of garlic butter for that extra oomph.
Tip: Use a blend of cheeses for a more complex flavor—cheddar and mozzarella, anyone?
2. Turkey and Swiss Sandwich
Okay, so let’s talk about something a little more substantial. A turkey and Swiss sandwich pairs really well with potato soup, especially if you’re looking for some protein to balance out the richness of the soup. The turkey is lean, juicy, and adds just the right amount of savory flavor, while the Swiss cheese gives it a mild, nutty edge that doesn’t overpower the soup.
I love to toast this sandwich lightly so that the cheese melts just enough to stick to the turkey without being too gooey. Throw in a bit of Dijon mustard or cranberry sauce (hello, Thanksgiving vibes!) for a sweet and tangy contrast that really elevates the whole meal.
3. Chicken Caesar Wrap
If you’re looking for something a little lighter but still filling, a chicken Caesar wrap is a solid option. The crisp lettuce, tender chicken, and creamy Caesar dressing give it a fresh kick that balances out the warmth of the potato soup. Plus, the wrap is easy to eat and doesn’t get soggy, so you can scoop up some soup with it like a dip!
Honestly, if you want to make it even better, throw some crispy bacon in there. It’ll give the wrap that smoky, crunchy texture that really complements the soup.
4. BLT (Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato)
When I think about a BLT, I think of simple, satisfying flavors—crispy bacon, fresh lettuce, and juicy tomato. But with potato soup? It turns into something magical. The smokiness of the bacon adds a little depth to the creamy soup, while the lettuce and tomato give a fresh, crisp contrast.
If you want to get a little fancy with it, you can swap out the regular bread for a nice sourdough or rye, or even add a little bit of avocado for some richness.
5. Pulled Pork Sandwich
For those of you who like a bit of hearty, smoky flavor with your soup, a pulled pork sandwich is a must-try. The tender, slow-cooked pork with that smoky barbecue flavor adds a totally different vibe than the others on this list. The richness of the pulled pork, combined with the tangy barbecue sauce, is just perfect with the creamy, earthy potato soup.
Plus, pulled pork sandwiches are so easy to make! Just pile that tender meat onto a soft bun, and you’ve got yourself a knockout combo.
6. Roast Beef and Cheddar Sandwich
Looking for a sandwich that’s hearty, savory, and just all-around satisfying? A roast beef and cheddar sandwich is a great choice. The rich roast beef complements the creamy potato soup, while the sharp cheddar cheese adds a kick of flavor that cuts through the richness.
You can go classic with a simple roast beef sandwich, or add a little horseradish for some heat. Trust me, it’s a game-changer.
7. Veggie Hummus Sandwich
Not everyone loves meat, and that’s totally fine! For my vegetarian friends, a veggie hummus sandwich is the way to go. The creamy hummus works beautifully with the potato soup, while the fresh veggies like cucumber, spinach, and tomato add that crunch and freshness that balances out the richness of the soup.
Add some feta or goat cheese for a tangy twist, and you’ve got yourself a light, satisfying meal that’ll leave you full but not weighed down.
8. Avocado and Egg Sandwich
If you’re feeling a bit adventurous, try an avocado and egg sandwich. The creamy avocado and rich egg yolk make a dreamy pairing with the potato soup. I love to add some sriracha for a little heat, or even top it off with some feta or a sprinkle of chili flakes for an extra zing. This sandwich is filling, yet fresh enough to pair with the creamy soup without being too heavy.
The Magic of Sandwich Texture with Potato Soup
One of the main reasons a sandwich is such a great companion for potato soup is the texture contrast it offers. The creamy, smooth consistency of the soup can sometimes feel a little too rich on its own, which is why a crunchy or toasted sandwich makes the perfect pairing. Think about it—while you’re spooning up that velvety soup, you take a bite of crispy bread or a gooey grilled cheese, and it just feels right. It’s that contrast of smooth and crunchy, hot and cold, that makes every bite more enjoyable. Whether you prefer a light crisp from toasted bread or the hearty crunch of bacon, the texture of the sandwich can elevate the whole meal. You might even find yourself dipping your sandwich right into the soup—because who can resist that combo?
How to Customize Your Potato Soup Sandwich for the Perfect Pairing
If you’re feeling creative, don’t hesitate to customize your sandwich to perfectly complement your potato soup. Want a spicier kick? Add jalapeños or hot sauce to your grilled cheese or turkey sandwich. Prefer a touch of sweetness? Spread some honey mustard or cranberry sauce on your roast beef sandwich. You can even get a little fancy with your bread choice—sourdough, rye, or a hearty whole grain can add another layer of flavor that marries beautifully with the creamy soup. The great thing about potato soup is its versatility, so you have the freedom to experiment with different fillings, condiments, and bread types to create the ultimate sandwich that suits your taste buds. The key is to balance out the richness of the soup without overwhelming it. A little goes a long way when it comes to flavor!
Sandwich Sides to Complement Potato Soup Sandwich Combo
While the best sandwich for potato soup is crucial, don’t forget the little extras that can turn your meal into something extraordinary. Think about pairing your soup and sandwich combo with some easy-to-make sides that bring even more flavor and variety to the table. For example, a fresh side salad with a tangy vinaigrette can lighten up the meal and cut through the richness of both the soup and the sandwich. Or maybe some crispy potato chips (yes, more potatoes—because why not?) to add a little extra crunch. Pickles or coleslaw are also great additions that bring a tangy, crunchy contrast. These sides aren’t just fillers—they complete the meal and make sure every bite feels like a satisfying experience.
FAQs About Potato Soup & Sandwich Pairings
What goes well with potato soup?
When you’re serving potato soup, you want to add a side that complements its creamy texture and savory flavor. A sandwich is always a great option! As I mentioned, grilled cheese, turkey and Swiss, or even a pulled pork sandwich work wonders with potato soup. You could also pair it with a simple salad or some crusty bread for dipping.
Yes, you can overcook potato soup! If you cook it on too high a heat for too long, the potatoes can break down into mush, making the soup too thick or even watery. To avoid this, simmer the soup on low heat, stirring occasionally. This way, the potatoes soften to the perfect consistency without losing their shape.
What protein to eat with potato soup?
If you want to add some protein to your meal, sandwiches with turkey, chicken, or roast beef are great choices. You can also add bacon, ham, or even a scoop of pulled pork to really bring the flavor up a notch. If you prefer a vegetarian option, try adding eggs or beans to your sandwich!
Do they have potato soup at Panera Bread?
Yes, Panera Bread serves potato soup! They have a version called the “Baked Potato Soup,” which is a hearty, creamy soup made with russet potatoes, bacon, and cheddar cheese. It’s served in a bread bowl if you’re feeling extra indulgent (and trust me, you should feel extra indulgent!).
Conclusion
So, there you have it—the best sandwiches to pair with potato soup. Whether you’re in the mood for something classic like a grilled cheese or want to go big with a pulled pork sandwich, there’s a perfect option for you. The key is balancing the rich, creamy soup with something hearty, crunchy, or fresh to really take your meal to the next level.
Now, go ahead—grab that potato soup, whip up a sandwich (or two), and enjoy the perfect cozy meal. Trust me, you won’t regret it!
4 thoughts on “The Best Sandwiches to Pair with Potato Soup (Because Every Bite Should Be Perfect!)”